"Lost Worlds" Treasure Hunt Ideas

Copyright National Lilac Publishing, LLC

The treasure hunt ideas on this page are for finding two kinds of treasures. One is the real buried treasure kids will unearth, filled with shimmery, sparkling “real” items from lost worlds not found in every junk toy and candy aisle. (Yet they’re inexpensive).

The other is the inner treasure found amidst group activities set up to make everyone feel individually valued while contributing towards a common group goal.

The childhood imagination ignited by these treasure hunt ideas are also part of the inner treasure to be found. I had so much fun with these treasure hunt ideas with my own kids and their group of friends.

(for treasure hunt party invitations you can customize or make from scratch, visit this treasure hunt invite affiliate Zazzle page)

Overview of how treasure hunts work:

What? You haven’t heard the story? "Pirates captured a royal ship and stowed jewels, gems, golden nuggets, royal crowns, the sea captain’s journals, princesses’ diaries, the queens jewels, and other treasures of a lost world. The pirates buried the treasure and just as they were going back out to sea again, a storm brought their ship down and they were never heard from again. Legend says the pirates’ faithful parrots survived and remain with the treasure -- and the first clue to where this treasure can be found....(fill in the blank here)"

The treasure hunt is a group activity that eventually leads the group to a buried or hidden treasure. It starts with a “story” (such as the one above) read by the group leader or an appointed child. “Long ago, a great treasure was lost and is waiting to be found…”

The first clue tells where the second clue is. The second tells where the third is, and so on until at last a final clue leads to the treasure.

Simple method for making and burying a treasure chest

Ideally our treasure chest would be antique metal with a traditional arched lid. In a pinch, select a second-hand cardboard box from a grocery store, and choose antique metallic gift wrap from a gift and party store. Glue the gift wrap to the sides and lid of the box. Oriental Trading Company also has inexpensive cardboard treasure chests.

An easy and clean way to bury a treasure is with dried leaves or dried lawn clippings. Make sure the leaves or clippings are spread around the area in various other piles, and try to find a natural indention to put the treasure in, so the buried treasure location isn’t an obvious large pile of leaves or grass standing alone.

Treasure hunt ideas for filling the chest

Want a treasure chest filled with real gemstones, sparkling and glittering gold, silver, jewels, and forgotten treasures from lost worlds? But one that doesn’t empty your own bank’s treasure?

No junk item treasure hunt ideas here!

Craft stores specialize in bulk quantities of items at lower prices. Search for the following items that come in bulk at your nearest craft store:

Polished stones. Boys and girls alike absolutely love intriguing, pretty rocks, and when polished they become beautiful gemstones for collecting and trading. Craft stores sell these by the pound or bag. They’re far more expensive when sold in smaller quantities in kids’ toy stores. Very popular for more authentic treasure hunt ideas.

Pirate parrots. Thank goodness your explorers found the treasure just in time to rescue the pirates’ parrots that were clinging faithfully to the outside of the treasure since the ship wrecked. Your craft store should have remarkably inexpensive feathered tropical birds meant for floral decorations with wire on their feet. Kids can use the wire to help their new pet parrots ride on their shoulders or bicycles.

Seashells. As the pirates filled their treasure chest with loot, they also added their most precious shells from their sea explorations. Shells are great treasure hunt ideas because they look irresistable when mixed with jewels and make the treasure sea-worthy. Children love to collect seashells. Craft stores also have beautiful shells in quantity. You can even find shell beads.

Large loose beads and gold and silver beading string. Treasure hunt ideas often include jewels of some sort. Turn the idea into an added group activity after the hunt. The strung necklaces and bracelets of a lost treasure really sometimes come apart, and what a coincidence, kids’ love to “put them back together” with a post treasure hunt beading session. If the children are old enough to do beading, you can find large, pretty beads and gold and silver beading string for the treasure hunters to divide up and enjoy a creative beading session.

Decorative chains. Boys and girls enjoy golden and silver chains for a variety of imaginative activities. Craft stores sell them for various decoration projects such as for hanging plants.

Mardi Gras beads. A rainbow of gold, silver, purple, green and other colors of metallic beaded necklace ropes make any treasure chest look bejeweled.

Kids love to put at least half a dozen on at a time. They're sold in bulk very inexpensively as they're used to toss out during parades and as store giveaways. Look for them in craft outlets, party stores or catalogs such as Oriental Trading Company.

Shimmery gold pouches filled with edible golden nuggets. Treasure hunt ideas often include edibles. Here's something unique. The wedding department of the craft store usually has small shimmery golden drawstring pouches meant for wedding favors (make sure they’re food safe). Fill them with golden caramel corn nuggets. You can even find healthy recipes online using organic popcorn and sucanat for the sweetener. This is another of my favorite treasure hunt ideas.


Okay, the following items *may* be in craft stores, but I’ll list surer locations as well. And these treasure hunt ideas can cost more, so may need to be left out, or may only be appropriate for, say, group activities with just 3 or 4 kids so you don't have to buy too many.

Sea explorer’s journal with feather pens. For boys and girls. Surprisingly, it isn’t just girls who like their own secret diary, boys like them also when presented properly. For the treasure hunt ideas here, the captain was a great sea explorer before the pirates captured his ship. Some of his as-yet-to-be filled explorer’s journals were deposited into the treasure chest. Book stores carry large assortments of “masculine” leather-look and antique look journals.

Stationary stores carry feather pens. Print out “Captain’s Journal” on your computer in an old-fashioned font, and glue or tape it to the cover. You can also make your own similar to the photo here. Paper stores carry old-look or leather-look paper and card stock for the cover and parchment paper for the inside.

Captured Princess diaries with feather pens. Girls also love journals and diaries just for females. The princess captured by the pirates also had some of her diaries deposited into the treasure chest. Book stores carry many “princess-like” diaries for young girls.

Princess crowns. The king’s treasure was being transported by the ship before the pirates took over, and they stole many princess tiaras. Coincidentally, they stole the exact same amount of tiaras as there are girls in your group of kids. While tiaras are more common among items for treasure hunt ideas and can be found quite cheaply as party favors, you may prefer to find somewhat affordable but better quality ones through a costume outlet, online or local.

For boys who need something to replace a tiara: gold watches on chains or old-fashioned key chains

Stolen, of course, from long-ago rich landlovers. Costume quality old-fashioned keychains and golden watches on chains (non-functional) can be found through costume outlets.

Queen’s jewels. Fabric stores are full of gorgeous gold, silver, diamond, pearl and other antique jewel-look buttons and fabric ornaments, which kids also enjoy collecting, trading, and stringing like beads or affixing to their clothing or accessories with fabric glue. Girls also love lengths of strings of pearls that fabric stores sell as trim. They can use them in their own hair or craft projects.

Treasure coins. What's a treasure hunt, without coins? Perhaps even real precious metal ones. For the most authentic replica treasure coins, The Great American Coin Company® sells pirate coins for a little more than 50 cents per piece when you buy at least 50 (about 28 dollars for 50 at this writing). If kids are young enough to appreciate mere pennies, pour in some brand new shiny ones that can be equally divided.

If you can afford it or can plan ahead, real one-dollar USA gold coins are beautiful treasure items. The problem may be finding just, say, two or three per child. The last time I asked my bank about the $1 gold coins, the teller had about nine she was happy to give me for $9 paper dollars. But another time I asked, they didn't have any and said you had to buy them in bulk in 500 piece chunks. (So, $500). Silver half-dollars are also fun because they’re not seen often and so seem like a novelty, and like the USA gold coins, the kids can eventually spend them.

Make your own metal pirate coins. Spray paint metallic gold onto washers of different sizes, including some with bondo centers.

Make your own edible treasure coins. If you have more patience than three of me combined, snuggly cover a bunch of round flat-ish ginger snaps or vanilla wafers with gold and silver foil candy wrappers found in party, kitchen and craft shops.

Oriental Trading Company has very inexpensive attractive gold plastic treasure coins.

Palace housewares. One kingdom was trading some of their finest royal housewares to another kingdom on the ship before the treasure was lost. And now, the treasure chest also holds some of the finest china, perfume jars and ancient antique vases you’ll ever find.

Find mismatched china cups, exotic looking vases and old perfume jars at second hand stores. For something unbreakable, interesting old metal keys, matchless old decorative silver spoons or ornate silver creamers or tea pots make fascinating and unexpected treasures for kids.

Making the treasure hunt a group quest where everyone is valued

Decide what will be inside the treasure, then rewrite the story above to include those treasures.

Find hiding places for the rest of the clues (which will be the same number as your group of kids). Then write the clues on bits of brown paper torn from paper sacks. (You can carefully burn the edges and crumple the paper for an antique effect.) For example, if there are nine kids, have one child read the opening story, then choose eight more different clue locations such as “behind the tallest tree in the yard,” and “near the left wheel of something shiny and red.”

At the end of the opening story, and subsequently at the end of each clue, describe the specific type of child who must read the *next* clue and be the first to touch the next clue, or the treasure may magically turn to dust before it’s ever found. For example “the next clue is under the bed of something friendly and furry, but must be first touched and read by the youngest child with blond hair.”

Make sure you find something unique and complementary about each child. This way, each child stands out and is important for the outcome. Plus, you avoid the unhappy situation where kids charge to be the first one to grab the clue and read it. The other kids can help lead to the clue, but the celebrated child must spot it in its location, touch it first and read it. If the child needs help reading, that’s allowed, but the child has to choose who helps. (If someone goofs up with this plan -- such as the wrong child touching the next clue first -- and the kids think the treasure will now disappear, come up with a cover story such as, “now we have to hurry even faster to try to find it before it disintegrates. If we hurry it might not be too late.”

Put the first story-clue in a glass bottle with a cork to be pulled out and read by the oldest child. Even kids from a same-grade classroom will all be different ages by months, weeks or days. It’s less tempting for older kids to fall for bullying when their elderhood is put to good use, like being the leader in reading the first clue.

Safety With Treasure Hunt Ideas

Naturally, items purchased at adult craft and second hand stores must be safe for children. Also, new information on problem lead contained in various items is updated regularly on the news. Do a current online search for items to watch out for, and make sure what you’re offering is safe. You may also want to consult other parents for their feedback. Also make sure you understand age appropriate safety before facilitating your own kids’ treasure hunt. Age related safety rules include, but are not limited to, the fact that small objects such as beads should never be given to children three and under, but may be considered fine for older kids.

You may also enjoy

Backyard camping

Backyard movie

Custom Search

Lots of treasure hunt invitations here!

Our favorite treasure hunt invitation (above) here!